Dunsmuir v New Brunswick | |
---|---|
Hearing: May 15, 2007 Judgment: March 7, 2008 | |
Full case name | David Dunsmuir v. Her Majesty the Queen in Right of the Province of New Brunswick as represented by Board of Management |
Citations | 2008 SCC 9, [2008] 1 SCR 190 |
Prior history | APPEAL from Dunsmuir v. Her Majesty the Queen in Right of the Province of New Brunswick, as represented by the Board of Management, 2006 NBCA 27 (23 March 2006), affirming New Brunswick v. Dunsmuir, 2005 NBQB 270 (4 August 2005), quashing a preliminary ruling and quashing in part an award made by an adjudicator. |
Ruling | Appeal Dismissed |
Holding | |
Correctness and reasonableness should be the only two standards of judicial review with respect to decision-making. The correctness standard will apply with respect of jurisdictional and some other questions of law, and the reasonableness standard is concerned mostly with the existence of justification, transparency, and intelligibility within the decision‑making process and with whether the decision falls within a range of possible acceptable outcomes which are defensible in respect of the facts and the law. If the question is one of fact, discretion, or policy or the legal issue is intertwined with and cannot be readily separated from the factual issue, deference by the court will usually apply automatically with respect to the decision made. | |
Court membership | |
Chief Justice: Beverley McLachlin Puisne Justices: Michel Bastarache, Ian Binnie, Louis LeBel, Marie Deschamps, Morris Fish, Rosalie Abella, Louise Charron, Marshall Rothstein | |
Reasons given | |
Majority | Bastarache and LeBel JJ, joined by McLachlin CJ, Fish and Abella JJ |
Concurrence | Binnie J |
Concurrence | Deschamps J, joined by Charron and Rothstein JJ |
Dunsmuir v New Brunswick, 2008 SCC 9, [2008] 1 SCR 190 was, prior to Canada (Minister of Citizenship and Immigration) v Vavilov,[1] the leading Supreme Court of Canada decision on the topic of substantive review and standards of review. Dunsmuir is notable for combining the reasonableness (simpliciter) and the patent unreasonableness standards of review into a single reasonableness standard.
© MMXXIII Rich X Search. We shall prevail. All rights reserved. Rich X Search