Alhazen's problem

Alhazen's problem is a mathematical problem in optics concerning reflection in a spherical mirror. It asks for the point in the mirror where one given point reflects to another. The special case of a concave spherical mirror is also known as Alhazen's billiard problem, as it can be formulated equivalently as constructing a reflected path from one billiard ball to another on a circular billiard table. Other equivalent formulations ask for the shortest path from one point to the other that touches the circle, or for an ellipse that is tangent to the circle and has the given points as its foci.

Although special cases of this problem were studied by Ptolemy in the 2nd century CE, it is named for the 11th-century Arab mathematician Alhazen (Ibn al-Haytham), who formulated it more generally and presented a solution in his Book of Optics. It has no straightedge and compass construction; instead, al-Haytham and others including Christiaan Huygens found solutions involving the intersection of conic sections. According to Roberto Marcolongo, Leonardo da Vinci invented a mechanical device to solve the problem. Later mathematicians, starting with Jack M. Elkin [de] in 1965, solved the problem algebraically as the solution to a quartic equation, and used this equation to prove the impossibility of solving the problem with straightedge and compass.

21st-century researchers have extended this problem and the methods used to solve it to mirrors of other shapes and to non-Euclidean geometry.